We are not wired for sedentary living.
Rome fell long before the Danube River froze over and the German hordes sacked the city. Whatever she might have been in the past was long gone before Christ was born. That’s because Rome forgot everything she learned on her way up.
While there is a broad general pattern of imperial failure, it would be foolish to nail down precise turning points. Too many factors overlap and the timing of events can easily get out of sequence. However, the failures are pretty much the same in principle, if not in fact, or every empire in human history. The same failures apply on the smaller scale, so it won’t matter what you call the particular human organization that is coming apart.
Even if you forget the entire matter of the Two Realms, there is something painfully obvious for everyone to see: Never wallow in luxury; comfort is a liar. All the decisions you make will suddenly become reactive because you imagine that you have something to protect. All the negative human emotions start coming out and controlling your choices. You will no longer see your world truthfully. You can no longer afford to pursue what you really believe in, because you won’t believe in anything in particular.
God has made us capable of doing an awful lot of things He doesn’t like. He gives us enough rope to hang ourselves, but every civilization we know about carries the same truth in her ancient lore. Once we are no longer starving, but simply hungry, we are at our very best. It’s not as if anyone can simply create a permanent culture of utilitarianism and Spartan self-denial. It requires sharing and giving generously so that you never have more than you can protect by yourself. We can all work together, but the root of human power to advance is having just enough for the immediate future, just enough to give confidence. Technology and cultural passion are the two greatest variables, but the underlying formula doesn’t change. There comes a point when our concern for tomorrow — whatever that means in relative terms — stops us from moving forward today.
That’s where we are in the West now, America in particular. It won’t matter what you imagine is the cause that brought us to this, who you want to blame, because there is nothing we can do to fix it. We have passed the point of no return. We are rotten to the core; there are no seeds to plant for the next season. We have lost that sacred balance point between having too little and too much, and now we really have nothing.
It’s not necessary to be a literal nomad, but so far, no one has come up with a cultural context that maintains the ethics and morals to give us that proper balance between stability and reckless abandon. Not a single civilization in the past has been able to capture the spirit of the nomad and keep it alive. In other words, you can’t build it — that spirit has to come as a gift from the God who made us.
The New Testament is loaded with imagery pulled up from Israel’s better past. We are always in the Conquest, always on rise and never past the days of David. We cannot afford to ever think we’ve come to the times of Solomon, because Israel began to die with him. Solomon managed to write a book warning himself about it, then promptly failed to walk in his own teaching. We don’t talk about returning to the days of Solomon, but we have an awful lot of “Davidic” this and that. Yes, David was a complete fool about some things, but every time someone chased him out of town, he was in his element. He did just fine as long as he was on the run.
Whatever it is God calls us to do has to be the sort of thing we can engage fully on the run.
-
Contact me:
-
ehurst@radixfidem.blog
Categories
I would agree that we, as a nation, are at the point of “bred and circuses” – too many takers and not enough givers. But that is as a nation – a whole economy of 350 million Americans and Canadians.
But a subset of that economy would be able to give us that balance between stability and reckless abandon. What qre the demographics (and geographics) of that subset?
Yes, “should be able to” — but not permitted. The plutocrats are raiding the system through various different means. It’s no longer a question of economy as national identity. As you know, the bigger it is, the more fragile it becomes. You once told me some portion(s) needs to be France-sized economically and culturally to remain viable. Provided no one takes leveraged action, it could still take some years, but empires never last on such shallow grounds as ours. Since I picked on Rome, you would recall that the part controlled from Byzantium stayed alive much longer. I’m pretty sure the Heartland could play that role because the culture and economics are much more viable than either coast. I suppose the South and Southwest could survive separately, but they have bigger problems than they might be able to handle. California is gone, as is the Northwest and Atlantic Regions. The Northeast can cripple along with big changes.
Of course, I wasn’t so much analyzing in my post as characterizing, as in the Hebrew tradition. It was meant to inspire, not really inform.