Long and Short

I had something else written up for today, but then I came across this: The Criminality Buried In The Epstein Files Is Worse Than Anyone Thought, And The Degeneracy Of Donald Trump Is Worse Than Anyone Thought.

If you think the title is long, you should see the article. Because I want you to read it, I’ll keep my post short. It’s just more confirmation of what we expected.

Posted in tribulation | Tagged , , | 3 Comments

A Harvest Is Coming

For some of you, this won’t be anything new. I believe I’ve been pretty consistent on what we can expect from this time of tribulation. The only thing new would be a few contextual refinements, things no one could have foreseen. But in broad general terms, nothing much has changed.

The major corporations will continue to metastasize like cancer, forming almost a separate economy. They are absorbing everything, consuming all the productivity and credit (future productivity) and crushing other sectors of the broader economic system. The rich will get richer and the poor will get poorer. It’s very much the Walmart Effect: out-competing all the little guys in town until they all close. The big store will capture all the economic activity, absorb all the business, and then drop the value of what they offer against the price, like any monopoly.

Right now, the stock market has no relationship at all with how us little people live. We aren’t included in their prosperity. We’ll be sucked dry by a rentier system. The coming economic distresses will hit the lower edges first, working its way upward. But the system itself will break from other causes.

For example, AI. All the available credit is being absorbed, to the tune of roughly a trillion dollars, to fund the build out of facilities. Further, all the memory chips and processors that the industry can produce will be sucked up. Whatever devices you have now will have to do, because the prices of computer hardware has already approached double, and it will continue to rise. I didn’t see this coming by my analysis, but by conviction. I upgraded all my computer hardware over the past year because my convictions warned me this would be the last chance for a while.

I’m still doing the same with my bicycles even as I write this, because the hardware prices are soaring. I’m buying from old stock when possible, because convictions tell me that bikes will become even more critical for my future activities, though I don’t yet see exactly how.

I’m watching out for censorship. A lot depends on the source and means of it. Under Biden, it was globalism that associated me with a large dissident population to which I didn’t actually belong. That was one kind of problem calling for its own path of resistance. If the current regime does something similar as a matter of course, it will be a slightly different kind of problem. Their methods are limited to a certain range of things.

If it starts to happen because Zionists notice me, it will be lumping me in with the pro-Palestinian cause, even though I don’t support Palestine. If the source of pressure comes from Zionist Christian groups, it will be associating me with the broad anti-Dispensational crowd, and that would be accurate. They would use a different set of tactics. It could be a combination of both, and frankly that is what I consider most likely. That would be less likely to result in censorship, per se, and more like propaganda attacks.

Propaganda attacks would include things like waves of sock-puppets trying to post nasty comments here, reputational threats posted online elsewhere, trying to get me kicked off the service provider, etc. If we add in the neocon influence, it could mean debanking and a host of AI bots digging in my background, or worse. I’m keeping an eye on trends in the political wrangling online. The problem with AI is that it can so easily fake stuff in my name that I would never support. It would be hard to think of anything worse than to have my message contaminated by fake material. It would be very easy to do with intercepting my email traffic or planting fake comments on forums I’ve never heard of (previously this was called a “Joe Job” when done manually).

But AI can easily do much more that we can’t even predict right now. Some uses are quite intentional, but we are already seeing uses that were never intended. Imagine those vast AI hardware farms directed to overwhelm the traffic on the Net so that ordinary human users can’t even get a word in edgewise? Passive consumers of content would never know the difference, but genuine content providers would suffer filtering. What if the AI bots were controlled by neocons? What about bots controlled by wokies?

It would no longer be necessary to assassinate people like Kirk if their message was swamped in the first place. I’m expecting to see something like that, as well.

Here’s the thing: Our God is at work in the midst of all this. Right now, too many people are comfortable and unwilling to consider their path in life. Only when their world is shaken do people stop and consider spiritual matters, when they have nothing else left. While a lot of people are going to suffer randomly, God is watching a small handful of His Elect who need to be shaken from their comfort zone to awaken. The numbers of covenant people right now are minuscule, but we shall see a good harvest of souls from the torments of the future.

Posted in tribulation | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on A Harvest Is Coming

We’ll Be Okay

We have a burden to tell the truth, even though we know the world will not listen.

Jesus warned His disciples of a fundamental truth: It is not for us to know the Father’s plans for human governments. He reserves His own counsel on such things. Instead, He gives us guidance that prepares us for what is coming on a different level, keeping our focus as shepherds over our flocks.

At the same time, His Word points out patterns and priorities by which He operates. This is what the Scripture calls “wisdom” — knowing God so well that you know what to expect from Him. As with all knowledge of persons, it’s not a matter of precise detail, but of general trends, so that nothing really surprises us.

The various covenants declared in Scripture give us a clue to God’s priorities, amplified by the record of how He acts when humans fail. Humans have drifted very far from those revelations. Most people who read the Scripture are coming from a totally alien viewpoint so that it requires a heavy burden of effort to restore the fundamental value system behind Scripture. Ask yourself: How many people do you know who would even for a moment entertain the biblical prerequisite of eastern feudal-tribal social structure? Yet, without that underlying assumption, you cannot even begin to comprehend what Jesus taught.

Indeed, the whole of the New Testament rests on that assumption. The Kingdom of Heaven manifests on earth in just that way. The whole concept of “church” is fundamentally feudal and tribal; it’s wired into Creation itself. The world God created expects to see this before it will cooperate with any human effort to harvest the blessings God promised.

Robert’s Rules of Order is anathema, a feeble human effort focused on everything except the Law of Love Christ proclaimed at the Last Seder. The US Constitution is even worse. We know what happens when institutions are built on such things. It keeps everything out of the covenant and within Satan’s domain. Thus, failure is the only option long term.

Some say that Civil War 2.0 has already started, and I agree. I’m not too sure the first one ever ended, though the human ideals for which people fight have shifted a great deal over the decades since then. What matters is the fighting, not what anyone claims is the reason. Those who lack spiritual guidance in Christ’s love will fight over anything, or even nothing.

I remain convinced that the real battle will be informational, trying to conquer pubic perception. The linked article is part of the propaganda war. What the author suggests is the solution won’t happen. That is, it might happen in a few areas, but not the locations where it matters most for the sake of propaganda. The Bundy style militias will react to a left-wing federal government, but not to bused-in lefty protesters.

By the way, the militia action at the Bundy Ranch was broadly justified and arguably lawful, but it doesn’t make any difference. Nobody on either side cares what God has to say about it. It was all under Satan because nobody was acting under the Covenant. All that’s left is discussing what might be effective in the given context.

We know what to expect from Trump in general terms; it’s all about his ego. He is wholly unconcerned with the welfare of the either the people or the institutions. Meanwhile, I keep wondering when he will be removed from office; his own people are plotting against him. Some of them have good sensible reasons, but if it happens, it will only make life here in the US even worse. The people at the top of government and finance are consolidating their controls over the economy solely in order to seize more plunder for themselves. They are heedlessly destroying sectors of the economy that don’t interest them, not realizing how the whole thing is welded together.

Meanwhile, the relative poverty for the little people will gradually creep upward into higher classes. The middles will join the bottom in struggling to maintain their accustomed lifestyle. It’s a slow rot. For awhile yet, it’s going to look okay because the higher class businesses will continue to prosper. If you watch the independent small businesses that cater to the common folks, they are already starting to close their doors. Only the big name-brand franchise shops remain open, and even they are closing outlets in some areas.

God will take care of His covenant people. We’ll be okay. Operate by your convictions because God will sponsor that. Stay focused on what really matters — love Him and His people. Be compassionate with lost sheep.

Posted in tribulation | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

It Matters to God

Re — Naked Bible 126: Ezekiel 18

I believe Heiser chases too many rabbits in this podcast. It’s not as complicated as he makes it out to be.

How many times did God miraculously spare His people in the OT? He caused three armies to fight each other when Israel obeyed and sent a choir out to face them. He destroyed the Assyrian invasion force and let the Kingdom of Judah survive because the king prayed humbly. So why did He not act against Babylon? Up to this point in Ezekiel’s prophecy, the leaders of Judah have been told in several different ways that they have broken the Covenant. Their hedge was gone because they tore it down, chasing idols.

Those elders argued repeatedly with Ezekiel’s message. They quoted a proverb that arose from Exodus 20:5 where God warns the nation that if they get entangled in idolatry, His wrath would fall, and it would keep falling on the third and fourth generations following. If you check Benner’s translation assistance, you’ll learn that the “iniquity of the fathers” is a concept based on a twisted rope that binds one generation to another. The generations are bound together. If you twist the binding, then the trouble takes three to four generations to unwind.

So, the elders there in Babylon were saying that the fathers had eaten sour grapes and the children’s teeth were set on edge (sour grapes caused friction between the upper and lower teeth). They were using this as an excuse: “It’s not our sins that got us in trouble, but it was our ancestors.” They rejected Ezekiel’s declaration of their own sins. They were misusing that passage in the Torah.

When covenant people engage in idolatry, they open the doorways to the Nephilim spirits (demons). Once those spirits gain a foothold in the household, it can take a few generations to drive them out again, if the succeeding generations repent and are faithful to the Covenant. Parents can twist the rope that binds them to their children and grandchildren simply by virtue of still being alive when those subsequent generations are born. Those children still live under the same roof with dad/granddad along with his playing footsie with demons. The entire household is still subject to his perverted authority.

That should be obvious.

God, speaking through Ezekiel, warns the elders in Babylon that this does not apply to them the way they suggest. It’s no longer a simple matter of ousting a few demons. Judah had pushed God way too far too long, and He was suspending the bulk of the Covenant. In particular, He was suspending the promises that He had given to the nation as a whole.

This is the same God who overlooked the sins of the people whenever the leadership were faithful. This isn’t flatly stated in the Covenant, but was a fundamental assumption of the feudal worldview of ANE people. If your shepherd is faithful to God, He’s going to bless the sheep on the shepherd’s behalf. Otherwise, Christ’s death on the Cross for the Elect means nothing. Blessings and curses work the same in that sense. That’s the nature of Creation itself; it is fundamentally feudal and God likes it that way.

As Hesier notes, Western people choke on this, passing judgment on God for making things that way. You’ll find any number of western scholars who simply insert their individualist assumptions into their analysis and insist that the Hebrew people evolved to a “higher” (individualist) sense of justice, so that they assign dates to the biblical text based on how much it reflects rising individualism. Heiser himself waffles on this a bit, generally uncomfortable with ANE feudalism as God’s actual design.

At any rate, we have Ezekiel saying that, in this situation with some provisions of the Covenant suspended, the people need to focus on their own individual purity and zeal for Jehovah. “The soul that sins, it shall die.” Jeremiah echoes this, warning that, while God had already surrendered the nation to Babylon, individuals could survive the siege of Jerusalem by remaining individually faithful to the Lord. It’s the same message here in Ezekiel 18.

For those who get hung up on the “shall die” part, keep in mind that this applies only to the Covenant people. He’s not sharing some universal principle that applies to pagans, too. This applies only to God’s Chosen, people who belong to Him. If you embarrass Him too much, He will bring you Home early. If you aren’t His in the first place, your passing will be under the Devil’s control. There’s no telling when or how those sad souls leave this world; it’s going to appear quite random.

The Covenant is the context in which God operates.

Posted in bible | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on It Matters to God

The Omphalos

Re: Naked Bible 124: Ezekiel 17

You can quickly discern who is a fake scholar of ancient religions by how they take the ANE mythology literally. Fake scholars (the kind typically hired for TV shows about ancient history) will talk about how the Hebrew people literally believed the earth was flat.

No, the Hebrews simply talked that way. Their culture was loaded with metaphor, much of which they inherited from other cultures and civilizations. The Hebrew language itself is fundamentally built up from the concept of parable. You should presume any Hebrew text to be generally figures of speech until the context forces you to read it literally. The very letters of the Hebrew alphabet are each metaphors that contribute to the meaning of the words.

Western minds tend to be literal first, then abstract. This is very alien to the ANE mind of parable. We see it in the Gospels when Jesus speaks in parables and His listeners tend to miss the point because the Hellenizing influence had bitten hard into their culture. Christ appeared three centuries after the conquest and very heavy influence of Alexander the Great, who zealously evangelized Hellenism. The religion of Judaism was the result of trying to inject Hellenized literalism and abstraction into parabolic sacred texts and oral lore. It’s an ugly perversion of the teachings of Moses.

Just so, we have a scholarly term we took from the Greeks: “omphalos”. It refers to a cultic object representing the concept of the cosmic axis around which everything rotates. It is drawn from the idea of the human navel. Not the shape of the navel, but the location is the point here. But while the Greek version of this was abstract, the ANE version of the “world navel” was parabolic.

In the podcast, Heiser refers to this by stringing together various parabolic images. If you can think in parables, then you will understand that the Mountain of God, the Tree of Life, and the Cross of Christ as all the same thing. There are a whole raft of associations that show up in how Hebrew parables point back to something that cannot be defined, only indicated within a given context.

It’s not about this world; it’s a reference to cosmic truth in the Spirit Realm (AKA, the Unseen Realm). The axis of divine truth does not exist in this world. It manifests in this world. There are places in this world, for various passages of time, when the focus of convergence between the Spirit Realm and mankind’s fallen existence takes a central place in human awareness.

God has revealed Himself in various times and places. For as long as that manifestation was a key to gaining peace with God, it stood as the “navel of the world” — at least as far as the particular audience is concerned. It’s the place where man can approach Him, and it comes with a collection of typical accessories. ANE legends are loaded with metaphors that show up in Hebrew language and culture — and in the Bible. Heiser links to a couple of documents that are written at his level. You’ll discover what serious biblical scholars have pulled together in their research about the concept of “navel of the world” and these features:

  1. It is the origin of all things created, as if the umbilical cord was connected there.
  2. It’s associated with the “cosmic tree”, including the Tree of Life in the Garden of Eden. Thus, a great many shrines were associated with the shade of some massive hardy tree.
  3. It can manifest in built structures like the Holy of Holies (a special room) decorated with (guarded by) winged serpents (seraphim) and other fearsome beasts (cherubim). It was the place to contact the divine.
  4. It was also the place to connect with nether realms. Thus, it often included a covered opening in the floor/ground with access to the mythical sea of raging waters and the beasts that live there. Alternatively, it can be access to the Abyss.
  5. The importance of solar orientation (facing the rising sun). It may vary between solar worship or simply observing the cardinal directions marked by the sun, etc.
  6. It’s the place where priests and other cultic personnel hang out. In some traditions, the Queen Mother figure is important.
  7. The association with mountain tops was common. You would expect written references to state metaphorically that it was higher than all other land features. But it was not as a geographic fact; the idea was its prominence in the sense of importance.
  8. Related to prominence is that it was the center of all things, the focus of everyone’s attention. It was often the place where food was distributed (the umbilicus again).

In the Bible, you will see the navel concept used as a metaphor. For example, in Judges 9:36, in the Hebrew text the armed men are coming down from “the center/navel of the land”, a reference to the ritual high place near Shechem: Mount Gerizim. The prophetess Deborah sat under a special tree for a reason (Judges 4:5). When Solomon held a great gathering before the Temple was completed, he used a high place near Gibeon that had been hijacked for worship of Jehovah. Eventually Zion became the navel of the world for Israel. The presence of Gehenna (Hinnom Valley) as the symbol of Hell should surprise no one, just below the ritual high place David purchased for building the future Temple of Solomon. Moreover, there was an opening in the ground of the site where the blood of some sacrifices was drained away. That opening in the foundation was symbolically reputed to connect to the sea.

Through the prophets, God speaks in terms of such concepts, calling Zion the “center/navel of the world”. Thus, when Ezekiel in this chapter refers to the “twig” of some future descendant of the House of David, he’s building the image of something that will grow into a great cosmic tree to be planted atop Zion. It combines both common images for the navel of the world, tree and mountain.

Posted in bible | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , | 9 Comments

Rehab for Fallen Leadership?

Let’s step away from the Heiser passenger train just a bit. We need to get away from the tightly controlled route to cover something he could not and would not have touched.

Over and over again, the foundation for our faith community is to embrace the Hebrew outlook of the Bible. It’s radically different from that of the West in general and American churches in particular. It’s not enough to simply get the intellectual background of Jesus. We must walk in His footsteps; we must live life as He would in our place. Somewhere between the divine ideal and the context of where we are today must be a landing place for us to find His peace.

Most of us come out of an American evangelical background, or are at least familiar with it. I’m sure most of us have at least read about the organizational discipline process for handling church leaders who somehow manage to break from their role qualifications. On the one hand, evangelicals confuse the roles of elder and pastor. On the other hand, the standard qualifications listed in the New Testament aren’t significantly different between those two roles: 1 Timothy 3, Titus 1, and 1 Peter 5.

  1. Sexually/maritally faithful
  2. Good manager of household
  3. Humble
  4. Gentle
  5. Sober
  6. Peaceful
  7. Financially responsible
  8. Hospitable
  9. Self-controlled
  10. Upright in character
  11. Committed to holiness
  12. Able to teach
  13. Spiritually mature (not a new convert)
  14. Respectable (and respected by outsiders)
  15. A good example to the flock

If you are familiar with Big Eva teachings, you’ll recognize the lists offered at Gospel Coalition and Acts 29. The discussion of qualification and disqualification is long established. It would be very easy to get bogged down in the particular emphasis and meaning different sources might suggest in analyzing the Scriptures, but our point here is that they all consistently approach it from a western frame of reference. The discussion is burdened with a big wad of western professional standards and the matching legalism. Rarely do you see anyone trying to dig up a historical context for what the Apostles wrote.

Naturally, it’s because Big Eva has a culturally twisted perception of what a “church” is and does. Paul didn’t plant public access corporations; he started familial covenant communities. The first century churches were extended family households bound by a common spiritual DNA with a Hebrew feudal structure.

The primary biblical image of church leadership is the shepherd raising a flock. That’s what the word “pastor” means – someone who spends almost all his time with his sheep. He loses sleep when one is sick, injured or lost. When he does sleep, it’s next to them; he smells like them.

Start from that image and read the list again. The primary objective of church shepherds is not shearing and slaughter, but herding them to the Law of Christ: to love the Lord and to love each other as the Lord loves. You invest a lot of effort in teaching them about the Lord who owns them. They need to know how Jesus loves them so they can emulate that. The whole point is improving how well this extended family gets along with each other, looking after each other’s welfare.

Every element of the shepherd’s qualification must contribute to that priority. Every time you want to point out any disqualification, it has to be something that threatens that priority. It’s not about measurable success. You don’t hire and fire a shepherd like a corporate CEO. Shepherds are not rated by the numbers of bodies, buildings or dollars in the budget. They are rated on how well they build a familiar atmosphere of cooperation and common welfare.

To be blunt, the flock should be able to recognize the shepherd by the smell of his individual perspiration. They should know his habits, what he hums under his breath, and what makes him angry. They should know his fleshly temptations, as he should know theirs. They should be eager to watch out for each other in humility and love. His problems are theirs and vice versa.

Only after you get all of that right will you be in a position to talk about what happens when he does something inconsistent with his role, something that threatens the unity of the household. Accountability should be built into the process. Recognize the problems early. Know him well enough to estimate what it takes to get back on track.

That’s what rehab of church leadership means.

The American institutional church norm of social engagement is entirely too impersonal and “professional” to make any sense of what the New Testament says about church leadership. Until you’ve seen everyone at their worst and made peace with that, no one has any business discussing dismissing anyone from office. Indeed, they have no business discussing forming a church in the first place.

Yes, we have a huge burden of social habits to overcome. The biblical image of “church” is a monumental demand on Americans. The problem so far is that no one has ever really tried, so we have no idea how close we can come. The fundamental image itself has never been considered. Instead, we have had any number of creepy cult groups and senseless experiments that have served only to enslave and harm.

In other words, the mainstream image of “church” is only slightly better than cults, at best. I can’t count how many times I’ve seen good men of God tossed aside because of silly legalistic rules about professionalism. At the same time, I’ve seen countless times a man with no moral qualifications at all ran a huge institution because he was professionally qualified or simply able to manifest as a celebrity.

God help us.

Posted in teaching | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Rehab for Fallen Leadership?

In the Twilight of the Empire

Following up from yesterday’s post, I wanted to point out that this analysis seems to pull together bits of outline I had been reading other places, and adds considerable detail that rings true for me.

In particular, it’s a good look at what it was like from Iran’s position during the supposedly “successful” attack last summer versus the failed attempt over the past few weeks. Those espionage regime-change methods failed because the majority of the Iranian population have no complaints with the government. They were unhappy with the inflation of their currency, but not with the government itself.

The surprising detail was the shorting of Iran’s currency abroad; I hadn’t been aware of that. It shows once more how you should not trust a currency exchange system controlled by your enemies. The system demands entirely too much vulnerability as the price for cooperation in trade. Iran would do well to back their currency with something that does not respond to price manipulation schemes. I wouldn’t recommend precious metals, because that’s a huge target for manipulation schemes, but something like commodities or even water.

For example, tying a currency to water makes the population focus on something truly essential in that part of the world, something already quite valuable. It would spur investment in harvest and storage, becoming the supplier of a commodity that other countries nearby lack. It’s value is already rising globally.

I’m sure there are a thousand reasons it might not work well, but remaining vulnerable to sworn enemies is not a viable option. The US is vulnerable, as well, though the US dollar has penetrated much wider and farther than Iran’s currency. Still, Trump is making enough enemies to encourage the whole world to get out from under the dollar. This is a part of what will plunge the US into imperial collapse.

Posted in tribulation | Tagged , , , , , , | Comments Off on In the Twilight of the Empire

Staying Out of the Way

The only way to understand Trump is to recognize him as an egotistical bully writ large. His own family says he was like that from childhood. Growing up, he managed to gain a sense of stage presence and charisma — the ultimate Alpha Male.

Whether it is merely an expression of his ego, or there really is a solid strategic case for seizing Greenland, you should not imagine he will drop it. He’s quite willing to alienate the whole of NATO and the EU to get what he wants. The problem is that the other NATO countries have always accepted the junior partner status. That worked well for nearly a century of letting the US spend its resources while Europe kept theirs invested in economic and social stability. It’s not working now.

I rather like this analysis by Moon of Alabama, even if I can’t quite buy the whole thing. I agree that the only way the EU can avoid the embarrassment over Greenland is to very quickly develop full independence. The article mentions military independence, something Europe can not afford, if we are being honest.

But it’s worse than simply military considerations. Europe needs to develop the entire range of military technology and supporting industries that rivals what they have been buying from the US. That includes the full range of military intel capability, like airborne radar systems. On top of that, they would need to declare technology independence. Do you realize how much of an economic drain it is for them to run Windows and use Office 365? That’s one massive chunk of global economic dependence. Microsoft is not entirely a global corporation; most the money goes back to the US. And that’s not the only major software dependency that holds everyone back.

You notice that Russia and China have already fielded their own OSes and software stacks, not to mention making progress in producing their own hardware. Microsoft is bleeding market share. Further, both of them have built up their own internet, capable of continuing in the absence of any networking with the West.

As another sign of who is calling the shots here in the US, it was Netanyahu who warned Trump not to strike Iran recently. At least part of the calculus was just how badly Israel suffered the last time they tried that. We didn’t get good reporting on that from the MSM; we learned by intel leaking through from people on the ground in Israel. The destruction was precise and substantial. Iran is not just a paper tiger any more.

In another direction, I’m not so sure if the call-up of Alaskan troops for action in Minnesota is just a cover for invading Greenland, as Moon suggests, but it’s plausible. It could be some of both. But domestic warfare is inevitable. The sheeple can be herded back and forth between Democrats and Republicans, but there is a growing consensus of divergence between two completely different nations. Soon, it will be necessary for lefties and righties to separate geographically.

On the surface, it looks like things are just muddling along, but the action around ICE is going to be what rips it wide open. Does it worry you that the division is also increasingly gender based? Younger generations of American men are increasingly conservative and refusing to deal with the growing radicalism of US feminists. It shows up in religion, too, as Big Eva is entirely too feminist and younger men are migrating to Eastern Orthodoxy or Christian Nationalism. Catholicism itself is deeply divided, and other liturgical denominations are fracturing.

As always, we have no dog in this fight. We can see that, by biblical standards, both right and left are too materialistic. The political and social agendas associated with either one is deeply morally flawed. We’ll be very fortunate if we can simply stay out of the way.

Posted in tribulation | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Staying Out of the Way

Identifying Abraham’s Ur

I’m chasing a rabbit here.

While listening to Heiser’s podcast on Ezekiel 16, he brought up the question of where Abraham’s Ur actually was. The issue arises where Ezekiel slaps down the arrogant attitude of the elders that they descended from Abraham, as if this were some kind of pure, royal bloodline.

God says it wasn’t so: “Your father was an Amorite and your mother a Hittite” (Ezekiel 16:3). That’s Abraham and Sarah, respectively. The Hittites we know about. On the one hand, I was taught that the label “Amorite” (Heb. Emori) could point to a specific tribe from mountainous regions. On the other hand, it had originally indicated a type of people who had a peculiar lifestyle of living in tents, wearing skins, migrating often as traders and regarded unfavorably more or less as Gypsies are in the West. See this reference as an example of that idea, based on the meaning of the name itself. It’s related to the term “Aramean” from which we get the name of the Aramaic language. I believe Ezekiel is using the term as a kind of people, not a specific tribe.

Heiser refers to this outline from Cyrus Gordon. Gordon summarizes the material he produced in at least one article which can be found here. Gordon notes that, prior to the late 1800s, everyone already believed that the “Ur” mentioned in English translations of the Bible was located somewhere near the site of Haran. The site had been identified as Urfa (today’s Turkish Sanliurfa) This was based on older archaeology about where evidence of the Chaldeans was found. They were all around northern Mesopotamia until much later than Abraham’s time, becoming the Babylonians. This was all well known up until about 1850.

Along comes C. Leonard Woolley, the first modern archaeologist — carefully excavating and making detailed charts of where everything was found, etc. Woolley identified one of his digs as Ur of Sumeria, way down on the coast of the Persian Gulf. Gordon is too humble to mention it, but he was there at Woolley’s dig and saw it all for himself. Woolley declared this site the “Ur of Chaldees” in reference to Abraham. Gordon rejected that notion and provided a lot of research evidence to support his rejection.

Gordon mentions how references to Urfa as “Ur in Haran” is supported by the rather recent discovery of the Ebla Tablets. He also notes that the biblical narrative describing the journey Abraham had to take to get the Canaan Land does not fit coming from Sumerian Ur. That ancient city is on the west bank of the Euphrates and there was a good route all the way up to the westward turn toward Palestine without having to see Haran at all. Urfa is north of Haran and does require passing through Haran and crossing the Euphrates.

Without dragging you through all the detailed evidence you can read for yourself at the links above, the languages of the time and place would deny that the Chaldeans had ever gotten so far south as Sumer until they had developed into the Babylonians. The names and locations just don’t match up back in Abraham’s time (circa 2200 BC).

There’s also that older scholarship before about 1850, with local traditions that the town of Urfa was Abraham’s birthplace. Notice that in Genesis 24, Abraham refers to the area of Haran as his birthplace. It may not show up in some English translations, but the Hebrew wording indicates he was born there. Please note: rabbinical scholarship prior to the 1800s also places Abraham’s birthplace there. Only in the most recent Jewish references does it move to Sumerian Ur.

If we accept Gordon and Heiser’s contention, this throws into doubt my previous speculation about Terah’s profession (which I also learned from previous research) as connected to the temples of Shin. Instead, the whole clan of the Bible Patriarchs were traders. This is what figures large in Gordon’s original article, where he says:

Abraham comes from beyond the Euphrates, plies his trade in Canaan, visits Egypt, deals with Hittites, makes treaties with Philistines, forms military alliances with Amorites, fights kinglets from as far off as Elam, marries the Egyptian Hagar, etc. His contacts and freedom of movement reflect a sophisticated milieu where an international order (such as the Amarna Age) made such a career and such enterprise possible.

See also this video on YouTube. You can find a bundle of Cyrus Gordon’s articles here.

Posted in bible | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on Identifying Abraham’s Ur

An Issue with Ezekiel 14

Re: Naked Bible 122: Ezekiel 14-15

Right in the middle of this podcast, roughly the 20:00 mark, Heiser begins talking about Ezekiel 14. Later at the 30:00 mark he raises a couple of small issues that I want to address. In Ezekiel 14, the prophet relates how the community elders came to seek reassurance that God was going to restore them to their homeland. The Lord responds that as long as they continue in their idolatry, they would all die in Babylon. They had erected their idols in their hearts, so Jehovah was not their sovereign Lord.

12 The word of the LORD came to me:
13 “Son of man, suppose a country sins against me by being unfaithful, and I stretch out my hand against it, cut off its bread supply, cause famine to come on it, and kill both people and animals.
14 Even if these three men, Noah, Daniel, and Job, were in it, they would save only their own lives by their righteousness, declares the sovereign LORD.

15 “Suppose I were to send wild animals through the land and kill its children, leaving it desolate, without travelers due to the wild animals.
16 Even if these three men were in it, as surely as I live, declares the sovereign LORD, they could not save their own sons or daughters; they would save only their own lives, and the land would become desolate.

17 “Or suppose I were to bring a sword against that land and say, ‘Let a sword pass through the land,’ and I were to kill both people and animals.
18 Even if these three men were in it, as surely as I live, declares the sovereign LORD, they could not save their own sons or daughters — they would save only their own lives.

19 “Or suppose I were to send a plague into that land, and pour out my rage on it with bloodshed, killing both people and animals.
20 Even if Noah, Daniel, and Job were in it, as surely as I live, declares the sovereign LORD, they could not save their own son or daughter; they would save only their own lives by their righteousness.” (NET)

Notice the three major figures of faith: Noah, Daniel and Job.

How would Ezekiel have known about Daniel? I can agree that Daniel’s prophecy was not published in writing until after his death. But why would it be necessary to have a written copy in order for Daniel to be famous to Ezekiel’s audience? As Hesier notes, Daniel arrived in the first wave of exiles, roughly 605 BC. Ezekiel was in the second wave of deportees, roughly 597 BC, some twelve years later.

Does it seem so improbable that Daniel would have written home at least once or twice during that time, testifying of God’s miracles? We have ample evidence of a regular imperial courier service, along with private couriers being permitted. Also, does it seem so improbable that his fame was spread across the empire in that length of time? I’m not the only one to suggest this; I learned it from PhDs at Biblical Studies schools. Why would Heiser ignore it?

As for Job, it’s the same issue we’ve noted before: The oral lore behind Hebrew Scripture existed long before it was published in written form. The story of Job could easily be quite ancient, and it’s the content, not the grammar of the Hebrew Book of Job, that causes us to believe it’s one of the oldest narratives in Scripture, predating Mount Sinai.

This was the same issue real scholars have raised concerning the Book of Enoch. The reason the Second Temple rabbis and scribes could write the Book of Enoch is because it was part of the common oral lore that Israel carried around over the centuries. If the Talmud wasn’t written for several centuries, does it not indicate that the Hebrew people were comfortable with keeping track of a body of oral traditions?

Sometimes I’m quite puzzled by the unspoken biases I see in Heiser’s output.

Posted in bible | Tagged , , , , , , | 1 Comment