House Churches

Re: Naked Bible 98: House Churches. In this episode, Heiser interviews a couple of men who have been involved in ministries and fellowships outside of the traditional institutional church atmosphere. This, of course, is something near and dear to my heart. This is another lesson that makes no direct reference to Bible passages, but you should recognize how this comes from the Word.

At times the interview banter was sharp and witty, but often loquacious. It didn’t need to take as long as it did, but that’s what happens when things proceed off the cuff as they do with interviews. Items that caught my attention…

We need not do anything that Jesus didn’t model in His ministry. If you pay attention, it was seldom “preaching” as we think of it. Far more time was invested in what we would call teaching. It’s not proclamation, but education. His most important work came after He alienated the freeloaders in the crowds who never understood His teaching in the first place.

His best work was in the small group setting. That’s where people really changed the most. He dealt with a lot of bored freeloaders, and His teaching got far more seriously once He managed to alienate them with His Bread of Life message. The crowds generally left Him and only those who really wanted His teaching stuck around.

The new term is “alternative church” if you need a name for it. These two guys generally avoid the issue of labeling their work. It’s just fellowship in private home settings, most often over food, along with Bible studies and prayer time. Sound familiar? That’s what we do together every chance we get.

Joke: After sampling the so-called “emergent church” these two guys decided the Lord was calling them to the “submergent church” to avoid drawing too much of the wrong kind of attention. They don’t view churches as public accommodation, but private family gatherings.

Question: What if “church” was not a time and place, but simply the people being what Christ made them to be? Nobody is waiting for some authority role or figure to give them permission and guidance. They simply began meeting privately over meals and not bothering with the formal structures. They didn’t “go” to church; they were the church. They grow strictly by word of mouth, no advertising, no website, etc.

The mix of people varies all over the map, from former staff of monster churches to people who had never been in a church. They learned early on to fold the Lord’s Supper into the meals they always shared when they gathered. Their meetings ranged between 40-70 people, typically in small groups scattered around the house, with no guidance what group you decided to join. At some point they are gathered for 30-45 minutes of teaching. This included references to the Second Temple literature, something few churches would ever touch.

Then they all pray and gather to eat. After the meal, a few musicians pick up a tune and they sing a few worship songs. They finish with testimonies of just a few minutes to encourage everyone in their faith. Naturally, people hang around afterward in unstructured fellowship.

There was a lot more to the interview, including how they do leadership. The leaders meet separately at least once every week, and it includes both paid leaders and volunteers. The outline indicates how easy it is to identify a calling for outreach to the community around them. These alternative churches each find something they do very well, maybe two or three things, and this becomes their signature.

Instead of trying to build little kingdoms, they help other people build their own alternative faith communities, their own “house churches” and the leadership will show up regularly to encourage those they are training. Aside from homes, they’ve helped to establish communities that met in a funeral parlor, a college dorm, offices, coffee shops, etc. Even homeless people got in on this, bringing whatever food they could afford just so they didn’t feel left out. The table is a great equalizer.

And this model works in China and similar restrictive environments.

The two mention The Didache (Lightfoot’s translation), an early catechism of the Apostles. They stressed that it wasn’t necessary to write new books about this; there is plenty of material out there quite adequate to the need. They noted also that the Day of Ascension was a very early celebration now totally lost in American awareness. It’s the image of having a King who is sitting in the Heavens that matters so much.

As for baptism, they’ve used every kind of water tank you can imagine. And this leads to another variation from the mainstream: Confession of your sins is actually workable in this alternative setting. It’s redemptive, healing, not punitive. People simply do this quite naturally once they get used to this different kind of faith community.

They go on to mention special outreach efforts such as campus ministries. They recommend you don’t rent equipment, just use whatever is available at the site you use. They say their biggest problem is lack of good teachers. They emphasize that you pray for like minded people, because they are always out there. God will bring them to you.

Posted in eldercraft | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on House Churches

OT Echoes in the Resurrection

Re: Naked Bible 95: David Burnett — Resurrection and the Death of the Gods – On the podcast, Heiser features a PhD student sharing a paper he was preparing for presentation at a scholarly conference. His thesis is that Paul’s discussion of resurrection in 1 Corinthians 15:35-50 is not based on Genesis 1-2, but on Deuteronomy 4.

Review: We know from Deuteronomy 32 that God parceled out the nations to His Elohim Council at the Tower of Babel. However, He separated out Abraham and his heirs (Israel) as His own nation. Deuteronomy 4 reminds Israel that they were not handed over to those other gods, so they must not worship them. The list of creatures Paul offers in 1 Corinthians 15 is an echo of the same list in Deuteronomy 4, not the list we see in Genesis 1-2.

Side note: The language of “sun, moon and stars” in Deuteronomy 4 refers to idolatry, as the pagans regarded those celestial bodies as deities. It’s not that Israel believed so much in astrology, but knew the pagans regarded them as gods with great power over human existence.

The Second Temple Jewish scholars regarded Deuteronomy 4 an evangelistic passage. It was the basis for calling out to Gentiles to stop worshiping God’s lackeys and to focus on Him as the Maker of all things. Paul knew he was not under the power of those pagan deities. The author cites Philo as a primary example of this thinking and did not argue at all whether such deities existed, only that they were secondary powers, at best.

Nobody doubted that humans could not handle this world without some kind of divine guidance, so it was all proper. We cannot stand on our own; that is a very recent myth. Greek mythology insisted that we must be herded by a higher race of beings (outlined in Plato’s Laws). The point is that the whole of humanity is incapable of deciding anything really important but are steered by higher powers. Philo noticed that this notion was wholly consistent with Scripture. His point was that Israel was not allotted to those beings but selected by God.

Earlier in that same letter to Corinth (10:20-21) Paul warns them to avoid participating in ritual pagan feasts. Even though the idols were actually of no significance, Christians were not under the authority of those demons and elohim (see Deuteronomy 32:17 and 1 Corinthians 12:2).

Then this author lowers the boom: You are no longer part of the nations. Your national identity was tied up in idolatry and control from hostile powers. You must leave all that behind; you must denounce your human national identity. You are now under a Covenant with Heaven; you have been selected and pulled out of that. They didn’t become Jews because that was just another ethne (human national identity). It’s a wholly different category based on spirit, not DNA and culture. This is the New Exodus.

It’s the same language used in the Call of Abraham as well as the Exodus. Abraham was taken away from the elohim and demons who ruled the pagan nations. Israel was not one of the 70, not in the Table of Nations. And who inherits the Call of Abraham? That’s what Galatians is all about. It’s the same language for Christians.

It also connects to the imagery of how every royal heir in the ANE was commissioned to go off and do battle, to defeat some enemy who held people who didn’t belong to them. God did battle with the gods of Egypt and defeated them. The Ten Plagues were a judgment on those gods. The language of resurrection comes from the image of Israel being dead under the power of Pharaoh. God brought Israel back to life.

The author with Heiser refers to the chaos Isaiah describes in chapters 24-27, and how God restores cosmic order. Isaiah clearly foreshadows a latter-day exodus of people who won’t need a verbal law but will obey from a new spirit. Instead of extravagant imagery of kings as gods, the New Israel will have God as their real king.

It sweeps in the imagery of Israel’s elders beholding God on the mountain (70 of them, the same number of Jehovah’s elohim elders who beheld His glory). The numerical parallels show up across the ANE pagan mythology, of ascending to a cosmic mountain image to celebrate the glory of one god or another. Isaiah promises the final gathering and celebratory feast. This is the Wedding of the Lamb, the son as conquering hero. The elders will assemble for inspection and be judged (Psalm 82).

This is all in the background, the context of what Paul relates in the key passage in 1 Corinthians about resurrection. Every time Paul uses the language of “Holy Ones” — often lamely translated as “saints” — he’s pointing to the Day of Judgment when the Elect will replace the Elohim Council.

The podcast goes on to dig into the terminology of the Unseen Realm and how it completely alters how we see the New Testament. The New echoes the Old in a thousand ways.

Posted in bible | Tagged , , , , , , , | Comments Off on OT Echoes in the Resurrection

Random Photos 21

On a day it was closed, I managed to capture this glimpse through the cage barrier of the south entrance to the Bricktown Ballpark. Being no fan of baseball, I’ve never been inside, so this is as close as I’m ever likely to get.

From the south bank River Trail, and within the River Adventure area, I captured this gaze back toward Downtown OKC. In a few years, the Devon Energy Tower will no longer dominate the skyline. Something taller is planned that will stand roughly in line with the charcoal colored tower from where I sat down to shoot this image. Despite the general economic softness in the US, Oklahoma is doing quite well.

That new pedestrian bridge is finally complete and the crews have left. A couple of days before I shot this, the Mayor of OKC was there giving an opening speech about the MAPS Projects (of which this bridge is one part). The little amphitheater there was half-full of staff, a couple of activist-volunteers and the press. The public didn’t bother to show up. I rode past and only barely noticed who it was.

Posted in photography | Tagged , | 2 Comments

Galatians 3-4 and the Watchers

This is based on combining two Naked Bible podcasts – Naked Bible 93: The Book of Enoch in the Early Church and Naked Bible 94: The Sin of the Watchers and Galatians 3-4.

The first is a fuller explanation of something we should have already absorbed. The Early Church leadership took the 1 Enoch seriously enough that some argued for making it part of the canon. He names some major figures in early church teaching. The primary reason is because it was clear the Apostles took the story of Enoch seriously.

I’ve already explained that there is obviously an oral lore behind the written version. While the book is obviously embellished with rabbinical nonsense, the core of the narrative is clearly referenced in the New Testament. It helps to explain where demons come from and how they act with a very clear strategy of persuading mankind to destroy itself.

Clearly, a very significant element in God’s wrath on sin is turning the Nephilim loose to sucker humans into self-degradation. This in itself is a form of punishment for rejecting Him. If you will not embrace His Word, you shall have more sin and self-destruction than you can comprehend. This is as important as natural disasters in trying to understand things like the Book of Revelation. God’s wrath starts with delusion and depravity.

After laying this groundwork, in the subsequent podcast Heiser explains how Galatians 3-4 are best understood in light of this. Adam sinned only once. The Fall cannot account for the Law of Moses because the Fall in itself is not sufficient explanation for human depravity. This is one of the myths of common church teaching, particularly in evangelical circles. Paul was well schooled in Second Temple theology, and that would include the concept that there were no Nephilim outside of Eden until much later. The level of human depravity we see leading up to the Flood cannot be explained by the Fall. There was that second rebellion mentioned in Genesis 6 but explained in the story of Enoch.

Second Temple teaching insisted that the Law of Moses was given because of the sins of the Watchers and their progeny teaching human depravity. If you survey the Old Testament, you’ll see very little mention of blaming Adam for the sorrows of the world. The strategy of Babel could not have come from the Fall alone. There had to be some outside source for such grand planning. What Paul writes in Galatians is best understood by recognizing that he had the Watchers in mind.

It’s obvious that Paul says the gospel does everything the Law of Moses could not do. The Law was a good thing, but it was never meant to open the door to Eternity. It was meant to preserve a nation from the gross sins of the Watchers so that the final solution could be born from that nation – the Messiah.

And the idea that the Law was not the pinnacle of revelation was already established in Jewish teaching. The notion of the primacy of the Law for the Jewish people is a common myth among modern theologians. It was not so. They felt the Book of the Watchers (the critical part of 1 Enoch) and Jubilees were more important. Those two books focus on the wider plan of God to redeem the whole human race, not just Israel.

Thus, Paul says the Torah was not really part of the Covenant of Abraham; it did not fulfill the promise God made to him. Enoch was granted this refined depth of revelation – a sort of tour of the cosmos – that is not part of the Torah but covered a much larger divine strategy that we think of as the thesis of the Unseen Realm. His revelation was prior to that of Moses.

Thus, for the believers in Galatia to hunker down from persecution and try to go back to the Law of Moses was an unspeakable tragedy. Take a look at Galatians 3.
When you get to verse 19, Paul asks, “Why the Law?” What was the point? The notion that the Law clarified what sin is would be missing the point. The grammar points us to the pre-existing condition of depravity arising from the sin of the Watchers and their plan to infest humanity with the Nephilim. The Law was never meant to help Gentiles, but only to set things up for His own portion of humanity. Their struggle with the Law would expose the need for a Messiah. The Messiah came to reverse all Three Rebellions (Genesis 3, 6 and 11).

Humanity did not become guilty because of Adam. Everyone became mortal with Adam. This is also stated in the Second Temple literature, specifically 4 Ezra 3:20-22; 7:116ff; 2 Baruch 54:13-22; Life of Adam and Eve, sections 12-17; these inform our understanding of Romans 5:12. The image we get is where Michael commands the Council and Lucifer to revere the humans who carried the Spirit of God and were made to manifest His image in Creation. Lucifer refused contemptuously and this was the birth of his rebellion.

The Watchers transgressed God’s design for them; they “left their first estate” says 2 Peter 2:4-5 and Jude 6. They seduced the humans and permanently changed Creation itself.

The mediation mentioned in Galatians 3:19ff refers to the whole Council being involved in what happened at Mount Sinai. Remember, the NT term “angels” covers all the Heavenly Host because there is only one Greek word for all of that, and no grammar to differentiate unless Paul uses terms that normally refer to “principalities and powers”. Moses was not the “intermediary” here. Rather, the “one” Paul refers to is God in a human manifestation (Deuteronomy 9:9–10).

Envision Moses ascending into the cloud to see God enthroned with a host of beings sitting in council, and the Living Word of God handles the tablets. Paul says don’t get lost here, folks – God is One. Read the rest of Galatians 3.

Now recall the scene in Psalms 82: God is not happy with the negligence of His Elohim Council. God is going to preserve a remnant of humanity with the Law. The Law is important, but it’s not the final answer. The Messiah is that answer. Galatians 4 describes humanity in that custody under the Law. The custody ends with the coming of the Messiah. The reference to “elementary principles” (4:3, 9) would be better translated as “cosmic entities”. And 4:10 refers to pagan astrology, not the Jewish calendar. Paul is denying that the celestial bodies are deities.

Also, note that Jesus being born legitimately (“under the law”) is in contrast to the Watchers and their Nephilim children. Thus, we see how Jesus reversed all Three Rebellions. We will eventually take the place of the Elohim Council.

Posted in bible | Tagged , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Galatians 3-4 and the Watchers

It’s Rolling Already

We don’t engage in political activity outside the Covenant. It’s not God’s work. All of it is under the Devil’s control, though not always directly so. His allies on the Elohim Council do a lot of his dirty work, as do the fallen Watchers and Nephilim. They are not idle. Never forget that the whole group hates humans and is seeking to destroy human life. God placed boundaries on their work; they are obliged to make their torment of humanity serve His purposes. The Book of Revelation, among others, makes it clear that those boundaries get relaxed from time to time. It’s what the Scripture calls “times of tribulation”.

It’s far more complicated than any of us will ever understand. The thing that matters is how every human activity that is not explicitly and consciously under the Covenant of Christ is by default under the Devil’s dominion. Who does not gather the harvest together with Christ is by definition someone who scatters.

Thus, it is a basic principle that we do not bother with human politics outside of the Covenant. On rare occasions the Lord will commission one or more of us in something that appears to us aimed outside the Covenant. Again, we will never really understand, but we must obey our convictions. You shouldn’t form any particular expectations about poking around in Satan’s realm. Just do the job and get out, because it’s not our world.

There’s an awful lot of stuff to which we pay no attention. The activism of Charlie Kirk fell into that category. He was not our kind of guy. The main issue is that he was a Zionist’s Zionist. That kept him outside the Covenant of Christ and well into Satan’s domain. His life was part of the looming threat of Zionism against those of us who reject the lies. For this reason, his death will trigger an increasing threat of oppression against those of us who offer insufficient support for Zionism.

Kirk had plenty of other very public sins, and we need not air them here. Zionism is the one that matters most to us. He was a threat to us while alive, and is a bigger threat as a martyr for his cause. We do not celebrate his life or death. Neither his supporters nor his enemies are our friends. What we take away from this event is the awareness that things have turned yet another corner in the Satanic divide-n-conquer strategy. Two equally wicked parties are competing to seize control so they can destroy the US, and we have a fresh increment of violence to contend with now. It will not decline; it can only get worse.

Martial law is creeping up on us, bit by bit. Friday, Rep. Clay Higgins announced he would use his position to enforce social media bans on people who celebrate Kirk’s death. Along with Laura Loomer and others, those people will be doxed and pressure will rise for them to lose all jobs, licenses, etc. Some have already paid that price.

And with more martial law comes more violent backlash as the portion of the population harmed grows. Hidden within that population, especially near the economic bottom, are a few people willing and capable of unleashing chaos in varying amounts. When they have nothing left to live for, we’ll learn what they are willing to die for.

People outside the Covenant have no real hope beyond this world.

Posted in eldercraft | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on It’s Rolling Already

You Must Die

It’s both doctrine and pragmatism that we are utterly dependent on the Holy Spirit’s Presence. Without Him, the Covenant of Christ is merely law. Everything we teach is utterly impossible without that divine power. In His Presence, any biblical law code becomes a manifestation of grace.

The birth of His Presence drives a wedge between the conscious awareness and the flesh. The flesh isn’t gone, but its power over you is broken. You gain the power to reverse things. Instead of its demands steering your choices, you are free to choose the path God has revealed in His Word. It’s not automatic, but it’s now possible.

The worst part about this whole thing is that the sorrows of our fleshly existence still register in our conscious awareness. The death of the flesh still hurts. Yet it is your mission to kill it, little by little. It must be conquered and occupied so that it is tamed and converted to divine use. In a sense, you are the one who supplies the willing choice to hammer in each nail, pinning your own flesh to the Cross. Everyone blow of the hammer causes you pain.

Each of those nails represents a turning point in our lives. At various stations along the path back to Eden, we encounter obstacles that own a piece of our souls. The only way to get any farther is to kill that connection. It’s an experience of death; that’s how you handle it. You treat it like bereavement. You must pass through the whole process:

  1. denial
  2. bargaining
  3. anger
  4. depression
  5. acceptance

Bouncing back and forth between those steps only prolongs the misery and keeps you from moving closer to the Lord. The wounds must heal and scars formed. The longer you live, it would make sense that you get better at facing the whole process. Nothing keeps the wounds from remaining tender for a time, maybe even decades, but it’s all part of our lives on the path to Eden.

You die again and again. The paradox is that for every hardened scar on your soul, you gain a new sensitivity to the Spirit. More to the point, you gain a new perspective on what it means to love your covenant brothers and sisters. You may also gain a new sense of compassion for those who are not under the Covenant.

And that’s the whole point. We get better at understanding Christ through His law of loving each other as He loves. You also get better at discerning who qualifies as covenant family and who doesn’t. The burden of deciding who is and isn’t remains both heavy and necessary. If you do not distinguish, you play into the hands of the Enemy.

To understand, you only have to die.

Posted in teaching | Tagged , , , , , | 1 Comment

Working Assumptions

We’ve mentioned before that we tend to favor annihilationism. That’s the notion that Hell/the Abyss is not eternal, and that everyone already there or going there will be annihilated at Judgment Day. Nobody roasts in Hell eternally.

But as Catacomb Resident (as Tomb Refugee) notes on Sigma Frame Blog, it’s not a doctrine. It’s just our working assumption. That’s because we cannot possibly know for sure. Heiser shared in a podcast that the statements in the Bible about Hell and the Lake of Fire are sourced from outside the canon. Jesus spoke about Hades (Hell) in terms of burning torment based on the common conceptions of His day, but it’s not found in the Old Testament in any clear statement.

Since He spoke so frequently in parables, it would be perfectly acceptable to use whatever imagery was popular at the time. We do it without giving it any thought, and there’s no reason Jesus had to waste time worrying about it. He spoke in the language of His people. John did the same in his Revelation.

At any rate, the sources on the imagery are ambivalent, suggesting that the Lake of Fire is both eternal torment and annihilation. We lean to annihilation because Psalm 82 depicts God as threatening the rebellious members of His staff with annihilation just like mortals. While the entire scene remains veiled in symbolism, it’s as close as we come to a clear statement in favor of annihilation.

When Scripture is ambiguous, it’s not a doctrine. The most it can be is a supposition, an estimate for some practical purpose. Our estimate is that the Devil and his allies on the Elohim Council, along with the Watchers, Nephilim, etc. already in the Abyss will all be annihilated on Judgment Day and the Elect will take their places in Eternity.

It makes sense of other things that are clearly stated as doctrine. We don’t put much trust in speculative theology, and we especially don’t care for western mythology injected back into the Bible.

Posted in teaching | Tagged , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Sin and Covenant

Once again, I’m going to ask you to think about the Bible as a whole as we look at some problems we face in getting our message across.

I’ve said this before: the biblical concept of covenant is not the same as contract. While you will find many church folks nodding their heads with this, their entire frame of reference still reduces covenant to contract. For them, it is not personal. When they read the Scriptures about terms like sin and redemption, their whole orientation is on contract structures and objective truth.

Two basic concepts will help to demonstrate the challenge we face.

First, there is “sin”. In western thinking this refers to something like culpable negligence or malice, in which there is a distinct guilt before the court. This is nothing like the biblical view. In Scripture, sin is contamination or defilement. The OT “Sin Offering” was not about specific offenses; the blood of sacrifice was not splattered on the one making an offering. Rather, your very presence in sacred space was defiling, so that blood was splattered on the sacred space to decontaminate it from your presence. The space was protected from your fallen nature; it made it possible for you to come before God.

Sin was not something you did so much as who you were as a mortal. Flesh is intractably filthy; it must die for you to live. It confines and defiles, entraps you in its foul will. You are in a tough situation needing to seize control, to tamp down its rebellious nature and bring it under discipline. But the only way to do that was to appeal to the God who made you and wants to rescue you from this slavery.

The solution was to render yourself — an eternal spirit trapped in flesh — decontaminated enough to briefly enter sacred space and present yourself as a supplicant, someone desiring to offer feudal submission and allegiance. This was not coming before the bar of law but coming to a specific individual who held all the cards, whose personal whim is your obligation. It has always been a matter of personal loyalty and feudal submission.

This brings us to the second item — “covenant” means treaty. Thus, redemption was not a matter of meeting some objective criteria but making a personal appeal. There is no formula. You must sign a treaty with your Lord. While the particulars will include a body of common elements shared with others, there will always be some elements unique to you. It’s personal.

When church folks hear the word “covenant”, they think of theology, of intellectual conceptions about faith. They associate the word “faith” with what’s in your head and your commitment to that. You must learn faith as a body of objective truth.

The Early Church Fathers (up through about 500 AD) seldom used the term “covenant”. They were too busy nailing down their intellectual traditions of Christology, Soteriology, etc. Lacking even a hint of Hebraic background, they never grasped the personal nature of faith (AKA, feudal submission to Christ). They lost all contact with ANE thinking, so fundamental to the Hebrew background of Scripture.

During the Middle Ages (500-1500 AD) they still didn’t use the term “covenant”, but it became synonymous with “law” in the western (Roman-Germanic) sense. Western feudalism was conceived as rather like a binding law of the universe that didn’t require God’s personal involvement. It all became a matter of status before the bar of law. It was wholly impersonal.

Thus, once the Reformation rolled around, the meaning of “covenant” was so badly contaminated that it became a reference to getting the right theology. You must obey the Covenant of Christ, and that requires a lot of formal education to get the proper theological frame of reference. In their minds, grace and law were hostile parties in a conflict. They had no place in their minds for how God giving the law was an act of grace. To them, law was legislation based on objective principle, standing separate from God.

Today, you can scarcely find an English translation of the New Testament that is not deeply influenced by Medieval or Reformation theology. The sense of all this theology is read back into Scripture in the very act of translation. The translators are helping you by narrowing down the definition of terms in how things are rendered, so that it’s not possible to go back and check what writers like Paul actually had to say.

When we use the term “covenant” with folks unfamiliar with the Hebraic outlook, it will be locked up in the prison of Reformed theology. Sometimes it’s better to use terms like “treaty” and “feudal submission” to Christ as Lord. This will help steer the conversation in the right direction.

Posted in bible | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Sin and Covenant

The Book of Life

Ref: Naked Bible Podcast #89

The concept of “books” in Heaven is borrowed from Sumer and Mesopotamia. The more ancient concept is “tablets of destinies”. Heiser approaches the question of just how much of our existence is predestined under the biblical Doctrine of Election.

NT Passages: Luke 10:20; Philippians 4:3; Revelation 3:5, 13:8, 17:8, 20:10, 15 21:27.

Heiser cites a 1973 article by Shalom Paul in the Journal of Ancient Near Eastern Society of Columbia University. The ancient pagan concept was that the gods would appoint destinies, particularly for important figures. These destinies were limited to how long these people would live. It would not cover the details of your life. In addition, the deities would record your actions and words according to their moral evaluations. This is a very ancient notion.

Obviously, we see only ancient materials written about kings because they can afford to hire scribes, so all the mythology is about the sponsors of the writings. Heiser also cites Andrew George in the Iraq journal (I found a copy here) from which he quotes a bit. It’s about Sennacherib pleading with the god Assur for a good destiny.

The point is not that you should expect God to keep a library about His people. Rather, it’s a parable declaring that God keeps track. He also makes the point that in 1 Samuel 23 we see that God had foreknowledge of things, but they didn’t happen.

David and his men went down to a town named Keilah, less than 10 miles NW of Hebron, down in the Shephelah Lowlands. David went down to deliver the village from the Philistines. The people were grateful, of course, but while David and his men were camping there, he received word that Saul had mobilized forces to come after him. David asked via the Ephod what was happening. God answered that Saul was indeed coming after him and that the town leaders would hand him over.

David and his men left the area. When Saul got a report back, he called off the march. God had foreknowledge and told David precisely so that those events would not happen. We need to shed the western logical assumption that foreknowledge always equals predestination.

These ideas are in the OT, as well. Moses mentions a book in Exodus 32:32 and we are justified in thinking it is the Book of Life. Isaiah 4:3 mentions a “record for life” specifically in Jerusalem. The same prophet in 65:6-7 mentions how God keeps a record of things Israel has done. Jeremiah 17:13 mentions things written in the earth or grave, the netherworld. Right along with this is Psalm 69:28 talks about having one’s name removed from the Book of Life.

Daniel 7:10 records a meeting of the Divine Council where the fates of the beasts were judged by the established record. Later in 10:21 the angel mentions a Book of Truth. Another shows up in 12:1, another mention seeming to point to the Book of Life. Malachi 3:16 calls it a Book of Remembrance. Psalm 56:8 mentions how the psalmist’s tears are recorded while 87:5-7 mentions that God is keeping track of those who were born in Zion.

While Heiser doesn’t mention it directly, we see a lot of this imagery in the biblical narrative regarding Babylonian and Medo-Persian rulers. From the Second Temple Period we get references in the Book of Jubilees to how Abraham was recorded in Heaven as a friend of God. In similar fashion that same source mentions how the Tribe of Levi was selected for priesthood because they had a zeal for God’s reputation. 1 Enoch 47 sounds very much like a Medo-Persian reference describing how God called for the records to be opened in His Presence.

Not everything needs to be seen as predestination in this image of God’s books. None of these references gets hung up on the precise logic of sequence. Foreknowledge is not necessarily predestination, though it can be. It is impossible for us to sit here within this space-time prison and pretend we can understand Eternity. Prophecy and revelation are often more about God paying close attention to you because He has a claim on your life. He notices what you choose and how you live.

You’ll notice there is often some ambiguity as to whether the destruction is literal or something figurative. Nor should you imagine this is limited to real-time recording, since God can foresee events before they happen. The business of recording is not literal, and it’s not limited by human restrictions. Don’t try to pin it down by your own reasoning.

Posted in bible | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on The Book of Life

Glad of That

Why do we bother to share the prophetic word? It is not to prove that God knows the future. The whole point is to warn people that the path they tread leads to sorrow. It’s virtually always a call to repentance, to prepare for something His hand might do.

I was not the only person who felt we were going to end this month at war. Some people with far more influence who warned about it must have gotten through to Trump, because he met with Putin in Alaska. The only thing of importance to come from that meeting is that Trump has a clear idea what to expect from Putin. He backed away from war.

Granted, war is still very likely, but Trump managed to pull us out of it (for now). Let the EU fight all it wants, as they apparently do. The US is still rattling the saber too much, and our troops could see action somewhere like Venezuela, but the nukes have been taken out of the picture.

For sure, I’m glad of that. I’ve got enough on my plate preparing for that long bike ride starting next week.

Posted in prophecy | Tagged , , | Comments Off on Glad of That